Halloween Eyeball Cake Pops I used a cake pop mix from the store and made the cake pops according to directions. The I colored a small amount of the melted white melting choc. blue and using a sandwich bag with tip cut out I make the eye. Then placed a mini choc. chip in for the center of the eye. Then I took a toothpick and dipped it in red food dye to draw on the lines. Next use another small amount of melted white choc. with red food dye to make the tissue at the top.